First, I want to thank you profusely for suggesting cutting the first scene. You were all correct, that has to go. I could go into detail about how fabulously it set up so much of the later plot and character, but I’m not going to because it’s irrelevant. It wasn’t working, it’s gone. Brilliant suggestion.
Second, we’re going to discuss Chad tomorrow, so I’m not ignoring your disapproval. He has to stay, so we can figure that out on Monday.
And now the next point: We have two protagonists, which normally I’m against, but for our collaborations it’s essential. That is, this is not a book about Anna who meets Nate, or Nate who meets Anna, this is a book about Anna and Nate, equally. Trickier, but since Bob writes Nate, I don’t dwell on it.
One of the things I loved about the idea of cutting that first scene (one of several things) is that Chapter Two, in Nate’s PoV, is about him at work. And the careers these two people have are crucial not only to their characters but to the plot and setting of the book. So starting with them both at work is obvious, except I didn’t see it until you all said, “You know that first bit in the pool house? Cut that.”
Then there’s the contrast in characters. The old “He’s firefighter and she’s an arsonist” never worked for me because I think that no matter how different people are on the surface, they have to have the same values to connect at a deep level. But differences are good, they can pull each other toward a healthy middle ground. Surface differences, same values.
So I have Anna, trying to stay in her lane because her mother raised to be a good girl because she comes from a large criminal family. Lovely people, just shifty as hell. So she never takes chances, always follows orders, is helpful and cooperative at all times. AKA: Boring as hell.
And then there’s Nate, happy-go-lucky, funny, laid-back, reluctant to take on responsibility, hates paperwork, very good at taking orders, very sure of who he is and what he wants. AKA: Fun.
You see my problem. I’m writing the dud.
Okay, they’re both going to have huge character arcs, but Anna has to be as interesting as Nate from the start or why would he connect with her? (Well, she offers him sex, so yeah, but there’s more book after the one night stand.)
Usually, I can do this with inner dialogue; what she thinks and what she says are two different things that gradually arc together until she’s saying it out loud. But there’s only so much you can accomplish with voice alone. And Anna cannot be a drag in the first chapter, especially since coming up right behind her is Nate being charming as hell.
So how do I characterize her?
The dog is important. The fact that she chooses the dog is huge for me. Then there’s the people she meets, the way she treats them. She doesn’t like Janice, but she’s nice to her. She has a good friend in Gracie and they trust each other, root for each other. The way the protagonist acts around people (and dogs) does a lot to characterize. She’s even polite to Chad. I think the fact that she’s a teacher and loves it tells you more about her. Later on she interacts with kids, but for right now the teacher thing is enough. So she’s a nice person who loves her job and is good at it.
Not enough. So how does she handle conflict because every scene should have conflict. And because she’s a get-along girl, she doesn’t. She caves. She needs to cave in the beginning because when everything goes to hell (that’s coming right up), she finally has to cowgirl up and get out of the truck, so to speak. But we’re establishing baseline here, so she has to cave. Also I need to get her to Atlantic City so she can meet Nate.
And that’s all I’ve got in this beginning, plus her voice, which is pretty low key, which is not good because Nate’s voice is loud and active and charming as all hell.
So this is Bob’s fault for writing Nate too well.
Okay, no, it’s my fault because I cannot get Anna. I believe I’ve mentioned this several times before on this blog. Over the months. Years. And it’s late in the day for this; Bob gave me back a pretty much completed draft weeks ago, and I’ve been staring into the abyss ever since thinking, “Why is Anna such a drag?”
Argh.
I am now going to rewrite that opening with a Better Anna, and tomorrow I will post the rewrite followed by Chapter Two, Nate, who needs no rewrite, the bastard.
34 Responses
I loved the first three chapters you posted years ago starting when Anna was checking out men as potential one night stands. We knew right away that the sweater sets and glasses might be signalling that she was a ‘get-along girl,’ someone who avoided conflict and let herself be pushed around, but there was someone else inside—someone who knew what she wanted and was not afraid to take action to get it.
Similarly, this good girl, raised in a criminal family and trying to rise above it, had no problem taking a gun out of her purse and aiming for centre mass when someone tried to abduct her. From the first page of that draft, it was a clear that Anna was trying to be someone she was not. That tension and the way the narrative kept doing the opposite of what we expected (the cop interviewing her about the shooting greeting her as ‘Anna Banana’; her mother trying to garrotte Nate) had us hooked. IMHO that’s what’s missing here.
You’re right—it needs more than inner dialogue, probably because Anna’s inner voice is always telling her what she should do and she does her best to ignore any voice telling her what she actually *wants* to do. We need to see her act, and that’s what we’re not seeing here. I’ll bet it’s there later in the book, though. Can you move it into the first chapter or give us something to show what’s under that oh so pleasant and oh so boring surface? I’d love to see Anna Banana in action:)
I agree, as I was apparently typing at the same time!
The original version started with Anna in Las Vegas picking up Nate, so we picked her up (oops no pun intended) where she starts changing. I feel I had her previous baseline based on the things she tells Nate about herself, and how self judgey she is. I know this is not helpful because this is now about both characters, so you can’t start there. But unless Anna has changed drastically, you had Anna in that version. We liked her. I doubt this is helpful, but I felt that after being polite all her life, she was being her true inner self with Nate, which is why she was engaging and I believed he was engaged. So we need to see her inside – I.e. what she is caving FROM. Again, probably not all that helpful, but since you asked, that’s where I went.
Yeah, I don’t remember at all what she was caving from or why. But that early-version opening in the casino had life. Maybe that’s one reason I hate Jason so much. 🙂
With janzie’s note in mind … what if Anna is NOT a get-along good girl? What if her choice of career etc is an open and cheerful rebellion against the criminal family history, discussed with loud exasperation on all sides every time she’s in their orbit, BUT they all love her and get why she wants to be a non-criminal outsider, as long as they can all live and let live? I mean, the 2nd cousin could be a platonic friend & avoidance of marriage conspirator instead of someone she scoffs at.
The criminal family thing had completely fled my memory. Becoming an art historian/educator would have been a pretty big risk and a big step outside the family circle, it seems to me; Anna would have had to fight for it.
She’d bring that My Life, My Way, My Choices attitude into her work life and friendships too, because once you set boundaries with your nearest and dearest, they get a lot easier to maintain with everyone else.
I’m kind of feeling Nia Vardalos in My Big Fat Greek Wedding here. Except to bloom on the page, Anna needs to be past the downtrodden compliant stage. Like, by 18 or so years.
Then she stays the same person throughout, learns nothing, and doesn’t grow so the reader gets no catharsis in her breaking through. If she’s a rebel in the beginning, she’s either going to be a rebel at the end, or she becomes a get-along girl there. Yep, I have to do something with her in the beginning, but she can’t be swinging wide there.
Does it really have to be all or nothing though? Can she be a rebel in one part of her life in the beginning, while still quashing other rebellious aspects of her life? Or she thinks she has to compensate in one part of her life by being ultra-meek, to balance out being a rebel in another part, and her character arc is expanding her rebelliousness (or whatever trait changes)?
That’s probably a terrible example, but I don’t think it has to be all-or-nothing. Change doesn’t have to be 180 degrees, as long as it’s enough to make a difference when it comes to the HEA.
I think that’s a good example 🙂 Also, since there’s meant to be a romance, and she’s meant to fall for a law enforcement professional, there’s a huge potential arc in terms of rebellion family’s already pretty much conceded to (career) vs rebellion they’re going to go ballistic about.
Just for the record, all that casino stuff is coming right up.
It just has to come right up faster. Hmmmmm.
Someone who has gotten to 33 years old, living a non-criminal life, but who come from a criminal family and still hasn’t made an absolute break from them, really can’t be all that get-along. It’s not clear who in her life wants her to keep going straight (her mother wants her to date and maybe marry a second cousin who owns a chop shop), but even if that’s what some relatives do want for her, she still was raised in, and to some extent still lives in, an environment where going along would mean going bent and it takes discipline and effort to keep going straight.
Nate is from an environment where going straight comes naturally, so long as he can have some fun along the way, but he’s rather lacking in goal-directedness and the discipline to do things he doesn’t enjoy in order to reach desirable ends. Anna needs to take more chances and have more fun, and Nate needs to buckle down more. Not unlike Getting Rid of Bradley in many respects. I don’t see a big imbalance. Nate may live a more exciting life, but Anna may live one that the reader will be more sympathetic to, because it’s clearer that she has a solid core.
What if we see her inner self through art? There could be some in her office or her work bag (either her own, or kid stuff) that she keeps peeking at or pulling out to hang but keeps putting back because it’s too weird / rebellious / colorful / provocative? Is that too much like Tilda and the Scarlets?
Or while thinking about her clothes having paint on them, she could long for something funky and out there (she does work in a museum!) but keeps telling herself it’s not practical, not her style, what is she thinking.
I like Anna now but I know you’ll make her better. Just don’t lose the sweater sets – they sent me down a fun worm hole.
I agree wholeheartedly
What about small acts of self sabotage? Not the healthiest, but I feel like I do things like stay up too late, go down a rabbit hole and download too many books, or do a big binge on art supplies when I am feeling out of control and need to rebel against my life.
Are there little, jarring things that Anna can do that push against her good girl image? Order a lot of racy underwear online to wear under her cardigan sets? Buy a whole box of donuts to eat by herself? Park in the principal’s parking space when she gets to work? Just enough that we can see the cracks beginning to form.
Ok, just reread the chapter which I should have done before. It’s probably too early for Anna to steal Jason’s parking space, but what about makeup?
The line about her not wearing any because only museum people were going to see her stuck out to me. I am not a full face girly, but I do have a handful of long-stay lip crayons in shades from almost-can’t-tell-it’s-there to neon pink. I can’t be fussed with applying more than once or twice a day, but I find a bright color to be confidence boost and good for distracting from bags under my eyes. Maybe there is a lipstick in grandma’s purse and Anna puts some on before going into the museum because she needs a boost in confidence? Or a piece of jewelry that she puts on in defiance of all that imbedded practicality? That way you can work grandma’s purse into the car scene if you are cutting the boathouse scene, rooting past the change purse, gun, etc to find an ugly vintage brooch?
Wait. What?
I’ll explain later.
Just put in your usual charming banter by Anna and whomever—just because she’s a good girl doesn’t mean she can’t be a smart mouth! And also, whatever music she listens to. Maybe a precocious kid she could interact with? Whatever you do, stay Crusie instead of overthinking it: you didn’t write all those books by constantly second guessing yourself! And think of Bob as the writing “wind beneath your wings” whom you can lean on “literarily.”
Oh, honey, I’ve been overthinking for years. I think Bob has a T-shirt that says, “Stop thinking and write.” Or probably since it’s Bob, “No thinking.”
But thank you!
I’d completely forgotten about the criminal family thing. Maybe that needs to come up sooner, if it is a big part of why she is who she is.
You said in the comments above that the fact that Anna chooses her dog over Jason is huge. So that’s where I would love to see the story start.
I would pay good money to read Anna v Jason as the opening scene, lots of useful info delivered as juicy conflict in the now instead of told, culminating in an important character choice and a big, satisfying payoff.
It reminds me of Lucy in “Bradley.” Lucy is a teacher. Lucy never says anything inappropriate, BUT Lucy blinks! And Lucy has an ongoing internal dialogue that is in opposition to what she says out loud. It takes about two minutes to “get” Lucy–and to love her.
Your analysis of Anna vs Nate cleared things up for me. You are an intelligent writer. You know what’s wrong, it’s just difficult to overcome.
I did not see the chapter or a link! Sigh. I don’t see well, anyway. Maybe it’s here? I’ll look elsewhere.
Also: the dog is important, but Anna’s mom is the one who coos to the dog and cuddles the dog and says nice things to the dog. Anna needs to emote on the dog, besides choosing the dog over the bastard boyfriend.
Jan, the link to the chapter is at the bottom of yesterday’s post 🙂
It’s not showing on my computer either.
**In one my all time favourites of yours Allie goes against type and has a one night stand with a hook up in the bar (who turns out to be her new boss). It is a really great book. When she gets to work everyone wants a piece of her because she holds everything together.
So Anna has a criminal family and is a people pleaser – so say that, but she also has a core of steel (as do nearly all your heroines). Maybe she just wants peace, an night of escape and fun without all the burdens -of being a good girl, but is missing her dog. So what does she need from Nate (apart from his magic wang??
Could she have been trained by her Grandmother as a cat burgler etc. and keep an inner monologue completely at odds with her chosen public persona? Being brought up as a very competent “outlaw” but choosing to live as a Goody Two Shoes could make for a very interesting character, and make the reader wonder what’s going on.
I’ve been thinking a bit about D’Vani Tendi in Lower Decks, who is a mild-mannered science officer on the USS Cerritos, but also, by inheritance and early training, the dread piratical Mistress of the Winter Constellations.
Tendi not the same personality type as Anna and I think has far more training as a criminal, but she’s also trying to put her family behind her but getting roped back in. If Anna has watched Lower Decks, I bet she feels a degree of kinship with the character.
What does Anna want? She has a life-a dog she loves, a job she loves-and annoying people who want her to do something else-her mom, the creeps. Then it’s all disrupted by the boss. Just like Nate.
Also-KJ Charles on the Odyssey
https://www.kjcharleswriter.com/all-blog-posts/the-odyssey-and-story-arcs
I just posted a comment that was way too long and apparently Akismet agrees and has sent me to the dungeon. Let me know whether I should try again and maybe break it into two comments. Or not.
I’ve posted extremely long comments, so I doubt if that was a problem. Including two URLs in the same post will send you to jail. Otherwise a mistake in the exact form of your email or screen name will do it, but since the present post went through, that’s probably not it. If you don’t have two URLs, I’d assume some random glitch and try again.
Huh. It’s not in the trash or spam folder and I just approved the only comment in moderation.
I have no idea what’s happening. Anybody else having this problem?
Thanks Patrick— nope, no links in my comment. I did think of you and your lengthy comments when I posted, but mine must have been longer. I am annoyingly verbose. There might also have been a typo in my email address, but it wouldn’t know that. I’ve been commenting on Jenny’s blog(s) for 20 yrs and haven’t broken anything yet, so I was overdue. First time for everything.
Jenny, it’s just as well it didn’t go through. I read the next post (re-write) and you fixed almost everything I had an issue with, so my comment is irrelevant. You nailed it.
Dunno if you’re still looking for input, but just in case you are…
Going off what you wrote here, it sounds like you are approaching current Anna from the perspective of where she is going (what the arc is). And possibly you’re more interested in who she becomes than who she is now, except in a stage-setting sort of way?
Which makes stuff about current Anna into a sort of eating your broccoli kind of thing, maybe? And all the things you list about current Anna and why she should be great are about why she’s a good person, not why she’s interesting.
So maybe trying to bring out what current Anna is trying (futilely, but she doesn’t know that yet, right?) to preserve and why it’s important to her and what she fears would happen if she can’t, and in what way things that happen might be at least slightly threatening to something she wants and why this causes her to cave would make her caving or not caving behavior more interesting?
I mean, okay, she doesn’t want to rock the boat, but what kind of boat is it and what’s in the sea beyond, at least according to her?
Because the instances where she does rock the boat don’t seem to phase her at all either. She’s not worried. She’s completely sure that she’s right. Which I guess is interesting, as a portrayal of a person who isn’t looking very far, but *sigh* To take the example that’s most obvious to me, I personally do not want dogs in museums, and have never seen a dog in a museum either. I assume that sweetheart or not, the stuff in museums is generally not compatible with the possible range of animal behavior, and that museums are not designed for dogs (and so far as I am concerned, there is no reason they should be, unless it’s a dog museum or something). So I realize this opinion and view of the world makes me not your intended audience, but … I’m really not sure that dogs in museums is uncontroversially totally professional behavior, and it sort of makes me wonder about Anna and her certainty on this point, but knowing that I’m not your audience, I suspect that no one who is not coded bad will ever have a bad opinion of her dog either, or her professionalism, or just not really like dogs that much, or whatever, so. I dunno, I guess what I’m saying is that if all good people love dogs and want them everywhere, then the fact that Anna does what she does is not something interesting about her. It’s just something that in this subset of the world that she happens to live in marks her as an uncomplicatedly, unarguably good person. And if that’s not the world that I live in and it’s not wish fulfillment for me, then probably I’m the wrong reader for this book. Which I do accept, I just don’t think it makes Anna interesting, maybe not even for dog lovers. YMMV.