The thing about the first scene a character appears in is that it’s the scene that establishes that character. You can show a character change in its arc, but the base line at which that character’s arc begins? That’s the first scene in which that character appears. So you have to establish a lot, but you have to do it while actually writing a scene, that is, a protagonist, an antagonist, a conflict that rises to a climax. You can’t just dump information on the reader because they’ll need to know it later.
What I wanted with Anna (see previous post) was a calm, intelligent woman who did not make waves. A little repressed. Somebody who thought a lot more than she talked. Somebody with quiet goals who tried to go along with everybody because that was easiest. A woman who loved her dog; she might not protect herself, but she’d protect that dog.
But I also wanted this scene to have the “day that is different” feeling. The day too many things went wrong all at once (ever have one of those?) and she was pushed to the limit. And I wanted all those things that went wrong to be her fault for settling for less, for not going after what she wanted, for playing it safe. It couldn’t just be a lot of people being mean to her; she had to have brought this on herself because of her flaw of playing it safe. Last thing: none of that could be blatantly evident in this scene. That is, on a reread, it should be plain that these people are reacting to her, but the first time through, I wanted it to be just A Very Bad Day. (Which is going to get worse.)
So Jason is a putz, but he’s a safe putz because she’s settled, which isn’t fair to him, either; he deserves somebody who’s all in. He tells her to get rid of the dog because he doesn’t like it, doesn’t want to live with it in the future, and doesn’t think it belongs in the workplace (all fair things for him to think), and he expects she’ll agree because she always agrees with him (she’s trained him to expect that). But the dog is too much of an ask for her and she says no, and that sets in motion a chain of events for the rest of the series.
Her mother is truly concerned about her still living in the pool house. She wants her kid close, but Anna is thirty-three, so it’s time she does something about it, ejects her kid into the world. Anna has three good reasons for living in the guest house–she lists them–but the real reason is because it’s safe and easy. She doesn’t have to stretch. So her mother is going to spend the next three books making her stretch, another complication in Anna’s life.
And then there’s Gracie, who’s watched her playing it safe for twenty-nine years, and she’s worried that Anna is going to settle for things (like Jason) for the rest of her life. So Gracie digs Anna’s drawing out of the trash and spray paints a mural with Anna’s signature on it, trying to remind her of who she used to be when she invented Joan.
And then, fifty pages in, Anna is so frustrated by the day from hell she’s had that she picks up Nate in a casino and the romance plot begins. But Anna’s character change begins in the first scene when the results of playing it safe come home to roost and she starts fighting back.
Now all I have to do is write it that way.
And thank you very much to everybody who chimed in. I learned a lot.
6 Responses
I don’t know that I got calm from the first read through of Anna. That might have gotten lost in the bad day. I got more frazzled and stuck, maybe a little frumpy. I definitely got the path of least resistance vibe.
I agree. I didn’t get calm. I did get the path of least resistance, and that it is the start of the day from hell. In her favor, she didn’t yell or scream or pull her hair out, she got up, got dressed and went to work, so I guess that’s calm.
“And I wanted all those things that went wrong to be her fault for settling for less, for not going after what she wanted, for playing it safe.”
This sounds way too much like my life.
That’s everybody’s life, pretty much. Taking chances looks so much better in hindsight.
She did not feel calm at all. She felt squished.
As I said on a different page maybe she needs more snark.
I mean, Jenny snark is always great but also, I think calm people don’t let stuff get to them. Repressed people who get fed up often cope with internal snark and snark to friends.
And the cartoon she put in the trash sounds like letting off steam through snark. And then being upset when it goes public .
If she has more snark later yay! But she might need it early.