It’s been a bad month for me and I haven’t gotten much done. Bob is being very patient–well, he’s building a basement gym for ducks so he’s distracted–so I sent him the first chapter of our next book, a real spitballing first draft, aka bad. He sent it back with two more chapters so we are now three chapters into Stealing Nadine, and that’s all I’ve read this week. It’s rough but it’s a good start with action (because Bob rewrote it, mine was just a bunch of conversations which surprises nobody) but hey, it’s a start.
And after my PT Evaluation today (ha), I will go back to the first book which is still nameless. That’s a clue, I think. Not sure of what?
So what did you read this week?

100 Responses
I’m really sorry September has been so hard on you!
Wishing you alllll the best for the next months!
Readingwise:
I finished Flagrant Foul by Jesse H. Reign. Loved the first 60% – the tension, the attention to detail of attraction, everything. Once they get together, the Reign-typical-explosive intimacy took over and that’s just not my thing. Still liked the book, but didn’t love it. Also: Although this is meant to be a hockey book, it’s not informed at all by hockey. The author could have chosen any sport or demanding profession. Actually, the hockey in there didn’t even feel demanding. It feel like a veneer – hop onto the band wagon that’s the current hockey trend.
Then the free-for-subscribers on audible made me start SE Harmon’s Spooky series about Rain, the medium and former FBI profiler.
I only managed to listen to the first book (PS. I Spook You) and 80 % of book 2 (Principles of Spookology) before the free phase ended, everything else is now behind the paywall.
I hate that the deadline is always just a few days ahead when you find free books on this platform. It urges me to rush through the books (I definitely missed out on some of the finer details in the Harmon books).
But I loved those stories (second chance for the couple, interesting cases, good atmosphere, only the profiling aspect is a bit wobbly): I will continue soon in spite of the couple really being into the smut, which usually is not my cup of tea, but I can live with it. Their couple’s dynamic is interesting. Some slight developments from book 1 to 2 that shows the author didn’t intend to embark on a series, but that’s okay.
Now I’ve started reading The Last Buzzer by JJ Mulder. Only 5% into it, so no feedback possible yet.
Also in the pipeline: Drawn to You by H. Henry – book 1 in the call-ups series. I like the idea of following a player who’s kind of not knowing where he belongs – in the AHL team or the NHL one.
Next week on Tuesday, a couple of books are due and my FOMO is strong. All hope for my tbr pile to not grow horrendously is gone long ago.
But at least we’ve got one national holiday tomorrow, so I’ll have some time for liberating my fridge from all the things my hubby collects…, for working on the front garden, for some chores – all that lends itself to listening to audiobooks).
I love SE Harmon’s Spookology series – such a silly title but such great books.
I had danced around the series for far too long. Don’t know what held me back. I’m glad that I took the opportunity with the audiobooks. The narrator of book 1 had done not too great job with another book but was fine here (imo), but Kirt Graves was really good with book 2 (imo).
I agree! I loved them!
Yes, me too.
Hopefully October will bring better things! (read the bit about ducks to my friend – got a well deserved guffaw 🙂
Best thing this week is “Beowulf: A New Translation” by Maria Dahvana Headley (2020), although I might like Headley’s introduction about her translation choices more than I like the actual poem. Headley has translated it as a tale that you might hear in a pub somewhere, which is probably close to how it was originally recounted in drinking halls. Mostly I’m uninterested in the detailed description of battles involving people I don’t care about. Nonetheless I can see the richness of the portrayal and how close reading would be rewarded by considerations of what makes a good king (generosity apparently), the value of possessions (ultimately not much) and the ways women walk in the world. I particularly liked that Headley is so sympathetic to Grendel’s mother. Glad to have read Beowulf finally, and I suspect this is a good accessible translation for first reading.
“It Started with a Scandal” by Julie Ann Long (2015) was a delightfully funny regency m/f romance. It’s a proximity romance between a minor Bourbon prince and his wonderfully competent housekeeper. Loved the banter, loved the tension between the MCs. I haven’t been that impressed by her more recent work so I’m glad this stood up to re-reading so well.
“The Last Sun” by K.D. Edwards (2018) feels a bit like a queer Hidden Legacy novel, an urban fantasy where the Tarot Arcana are the closest things to Gods, and live in a city on Nantucket. The MMC is the heir to the Sun arcana and basically it’s a fun adventure with found family, politics and monsters. Looking forward to the next one.
‘It Started with a Scandal’ sounds like fun, I’ll check it out.
Hope you enjoy it 🙂
Thank you reminding me! I also enjoyed Julie Ann Long’s “It Started with a Scandal” and need to remember to reread that one. I recently reread “The Runaway Duke” which is one of my all time favorite of hers. The story of a Duke who fakes his death at Waterloo and then a few years later has to return. I won’t spoil any more but it was fun, romantic, well written and had great dialogue. I also have been less than impressed with her recent stuff. I keep hoping that spark will come back but it hasn’t so far.
It’s been a while since I’ve read Julie Anne Long but I don’t think I read It Started with a Scandal so I will look for that one.
I liked the whole pennyroyal green series. One of them involved a scene with a gun and a statue that reduced me to helpless giggles.
I kind of had to push myself to read her contemps and I am not sure why because they were good. I have not enjoyed her more recent series .
Yuri, I was really interested in your comment about how generosity makes a good king. I used to live on the Gazelle Peninsula in Papua New Guinea, and the way men gained status in the Tolai community was to give away shell money. It was a huge ceremonial thing, and the more you could give away, the more important you became.
Maybe its one of those things like guesting rules that turns up in multiple ancient cultures?
Living in PNG must have been fascinating, but I imagine also quite challenging?
Yes, very similar to guesting rules in some ways. And a really nice counter to what seems to have become the prevailing Western sign of wealth and importance, which consists mostly of hoarding one’s wealth.
PNG was wonderful. At the time (1974-76), it was one of those places that looks very dangerous from the outside but isn’t really when you’re living there. At least, not for Anglos. (It was then and continues to be one of the most dangerous places in the world to be a local woman.)
Port Moresby was starting to get more unsettled, but the Gazelle Peninsula was a lot more cohesive culturally, and therefore a lot less volatile. Plus I was employed by a school that was owned and run by Tolais, so although it was the time of Independence, and there had been quite a bit of disruption and resentment around expatriate ownership of land, I got a pass because I was working for the local people.
That sounds marvelous. And it is funny how that works – the external perception of danger vs the lived experience – at least for expats.
After watching Nuremburg the movie, I decided to listen to the book the film is based on, The Nazi and the Psychiatrist by Jack El-Hal about Doug Kelley, the psychiatrist sent to assess whether the 22 leaders of Germany’s high command were competent to face trial. Surprisingly crisp, coming in under nine hours, this book is as much a biography of Kelley who used magician’s tricks and the Rorschach test with equal weight in his practice. He came to identify uncomfortably with his key subject Hermann Goring with long lasting consequences for him. A fascinating read.
I also listened to Penric and the Bandit which is one of my favourite novellas in this series so far. A quest, a bandit who might be redeemable , sprinkled with some theology and some delightful action.
Ali Hazelwood’s newest, Hot for Slayer, was super fun. A centuries old vampire is pursued by her nemesis, a slayer who is pledged to kill her, hence his title. A nice refresh on the enemies to lovers trope.
And now for the hockey update. I read both books of Marina Vivancos’ Full Body Hit (it really is one book in two parts). This is one of her alpha-omega series and crosses the line from smutty to kinky in the first book so isn’t for all audiences, although weirdly the smut and the hockey are intertwined, kinda, don’t ask. Wasn’t my favourite of this series. I also read A.L. Heard’s Brady’s Story, only for those who read Hockey Bois and reading it reminded me how good that original book was. I’m now making my way through The Fall which is more interesting than I expected, and Hannah Henry’s newest came out yesterday. What with the Leafs’ first regular season coming up next week, It’s a great time to be alive.
Tammy, I saw that amazon has a pub date for the next in Henry’s new series The Call-ups, so if Drawn to You is sound, It’s only another 6 months until Buzzed on You comes out at the end of March 2026…
How delightful!
Thanks for the positive rec for the Ali Hazelwood, she is churning them out so fast I thought it wouldn’t be worth it!
I check the price of Hockey Bois every so often, I see it has now come down a bit but will still be more than €9 so i’ll wait … or should I go for it? I did enjoy Trade Deadline though, and I see she has another coming out.
Hockey Bois is a a long smoulder of a romance, and I really enjoyed it. She cut out all the sex scenes and put them into a separate doc. So if it’s not easily available, let me know.
Drop the Gloves is out next Tuesday, FrozenPond!
I maybe should read the Nuremberg book. My dad, who fled Germany in 1939 and who lost 2 grandparents and an uncle to concentration camps, returned in the USArmy. He was an interpreter for the war crimes investigation committee and then was forced to interpret for the defense at Dachau (trials of the heads of concentration camps, so he didn’t know if he was defending the people who killed his family.)
My DH once asked if he had been tempted to interpret wrongly to get them convicted and dad said “ there was no need. They were proud of what they did and happy to talk about it.”
Wow that is fascinating. And horrible.
Two good ones from me this week (and one midway DNF, which always seems such a waste).
The first ‘Sailor’s Delight’ by Rose Lerner is a regency MM with one MC a ship’s Master and the other a naval agent. I really enjoyed this. It is very slow burn with little or no smut and the MCs are both sweet, lovely characters with different issues. The best thing about it though is the historical background and insight into both careers and how the pay and prize systems worked in practice. This was fascinating and there was a nice picture of regency Portsmouth. Elie (the agent) is from a large Jewish family and the book is set during a period of holy days. This was interesting, as was the depiction of Jewish life during that period. Not unusually the cover is awful and bears absolutely no relation to the type of content, so don’t let it put you off.
Next one was the latest Sasha Avice ‘On the Land We Shoot Straight’ which is a western farm/ranch based MM set in the early 1980s. Grady inherited a farm when he was 17 and works it alone, his wife has moved back to the city, and Cole arrives looking for work. There isn’t a lot of plot but the book is excellent on the developing relationship and while it is mostly just the two of them, visits to town give other perspectives. As expected in this setting there is not a lot of talking but lots of horsey stuff, and farming too. It is fairly angsty, in quite a realistic way, the pacing is very good and I never lost interest (I don’t take that for granted!). Not sure I am selling this, but I thought it was excellent.
The DNF was NR Walker’s Galaxies and Oceans, which didn’t hold my interest, it either didn’t have enough plot, or didn’t explore the angsty issues is set out with. I assume there was some sort of big resolution with bad ex getting his desserts, but I didn’t stick around for that. Disappointing, as I had liked ‘The Weight of it All’ and thought I would enjoy this one. It does start well, and the characters are nice enough.
On audio I mainly continued my way though early Josh Lanyon shorts.
‘This Rough Magic’ a 1930s rich boy /PI with missing manuscript was the weakest of the lot, and felt like a very early book (I find it hard to work out when they were actually published when I am listening).
‘Don’t look back’ was better, a curator is accused of stealing from the museum and ends up in a relationship with the detective investigator. Amnesia trope, and some of the plot was not very believable, but it was enjoyable enough.
Finally, I am well though ‘Murder in Pastel’ which is so far the best of the lot, better developed characters and it is not clear how it will end. It’s going to be a cliffhanger for me as I will have run out of Spotify audio time before the end!
“Sailor’s Delight” is my last unread Lerner – glad to hear its as good as the rest 🙂
The Sasha Avice sounds good – I like books that focus on the relationship to the exclusion of all else. Putting it on my list.
“Sailor’s Delight” was such a lovely read. Thank you for reminding me of it.
“Murder in Pastel” is an interesting Lanyon. I enjoyed it though it seemed to me to be an “early” book and a tryout for some of her later characters in other books. Must reread. “Don’t look back” is on my reread loop (though I agree with you that it requires some suspension of disbelief…)
I’ve just added “On the Land We Shoot Straight” to my tbr!
Something triggered me to reread Sweet Dreams by Kristen Ashley. It’s the second book in her Colorado Mountain Man series. It’s a very good book from a very good series.
I have also been enjoying the TV series The Morning Show. It’s really good!
I have just started a reread of Ghost Hunter by Jayne Castle.
I don’t normally reread books, but I have reread Sweet Dreams also.
I picked up Emily Henry’s “Funny Story” and really enjoyed it. The premise is that a woman is dumped by her fiance 3 monhts before the wedding, because he’s decided he wants to marry his childhood best friend. The MC, in trying to decide where she should move, as the house is in her ex’s name, moves in with the new fiance’s ex, who had also been dumped. I know, rather tangled, but the shared trauma helps them bond. There is family stuff on both sides, there are misunderstandings, there is personal growth as the MC tries to figure out who she is on her own. Set in Michigan, the MC is a librarian, and has a passion for her job, which was also a plus for me.
Currently rereading the Seducing the Sedgwicks series by Cat Sebastian. It’s solid 4 stars for me really good but not mind blowing.
I’ve just finished listening to the Murderbot diaries yet again, mostly while I work. I like the first four books best, but once I’m through those have to listen to the rest, obviously.
Next up: some thriller for book group.
Then I’ll treat myself and get the audio for KJ Charles’ upcoming book All of Us Murderers which I got the ebook Arc of and have already read 3 times because it is that good.. It’s the most Gothic of her Gothic-leanimg books and also the main character is very aware that it’s it’s Gothic.
I can hardly wait for “All of Us Murderers.” 🙂 One of the best things about KJC is the way her characters interact with their world. They are not simply people doing things in a static image of a world (a collage of famous paintings and fashion books scribbled over with Georgette Heyerisms), as in so many historical romances. They are both self-aware and socially conscious without being anachronistic.
Jenny, I hope all the Bad Things were concentrated in September and are behind you now and that the coming months bring only Good Things.
Last week’s brief discussion about Joseph Hanson reminded me to that it was time for me to reread Alan Hollinghurst’s “Line of Beauty” — one of my favorite books. It’s the story of a young middle class gay man who moves to London and stays in the home of the parents of a (straight) “crush” of his from Oxford. The “crush”s father is an upper class conservative member of Parliament during the early Thatcher years and the story takes place at a time when homosexuality had only recently been de-criminalized. Though AIDS makes an appearance, it is there as a looming threat not yet fully understood. This novel is wonderful: it’s subtly very funny and touching, and it paints a brilliant picture of the gulf between social classes in the UK and of the whole Thatcher era. It is a great snapshot of early 1980s London.
I then DNF’d a series of books on Kindle Unlimited and settled on NR Walker’s “Finder’s Keepers” which was fine but which I abandoned at the 70% mark cause the stakes weren’t high enough and I lost interest in the characters. I might go back to check out the HEA at some point.
Finally, the hockey season starts imminently and to get fully ready I reread “You Could Make a Life” by Taylor Fitzpatrick, an M/M romance between teammates. It remains excellent and a reminder that for all the hockey romances out there, Taylor Fitzpatrick has no equal (imho.)
Dang. I’m sorry to hear the NR Walker wasn’t great, especially after how impressed I was with The Weight of It All.
Yes, I love Taylor Fitzpatrick. I’m keeping up with Always in a Tandem (one of my favourites) and Cards on the Table as episodes come out.
I am waiting for her to finish Still Always in Tandem because I followed it up to when she took the hiatus and it KILLED me to wait so long between installments. I wish she would finish it already so I can reread from the start and get the whole story.
It’s getting towards the end. I’d say it’ll be finished by Christmas, and it might even be sooner than that!
I live for those episodes.
I’m sorry that the last few months have been rough and hope things get better soon. I hope you can spend lots of lovely time soaking up nature and petting Johnny.
Lately I’ve read the most recent book in various series I follow. Grace Burrowes continued the saga of Lord Julian (number 10) with A Gentleman in Possession of Secrets. It was an amusing story of a missing bluestocking heiress. It was up to her usual standard of investigating and uncovering motives. I recommend it. (But I really hope he marries Perry soon because those trials and tribulations have gone on too long.)
I also listened to Heathcliff Lennox number 13, The Twelve Saints of Christmas, which was satisfying. I’m continually amazed how he always travels with his dog, cat, and butler, leaving his beloved clever wife behind. They are all warmly welcomed into every household and establishment, no apparent snide comments about accidents, ruined upholstery or gratuitous hair shedding. Okay, yes, it is fiction after all. I’m also impressed that Karen Baugh Menuhin takes the genre and makes something fresh of each story. And she seems to throw in bits of unusual history to add to the fun.
I read The Hallmarked Man by Robert Galbraith. It was sooo long—1213 pages in Libby. I found it totally immersive. I really enjoy reading the strategizing, detailed interviews, and “rota” problems of their cases. The plot was (as usual) very complicated and the suspects’ relationships were twisted. And one of the team (as usual) gets damaged. But it was very refreshing in that it focused in depth on Robin and Strike’s romantic relationship. That’s another couple that needs to fish or cut bait. I suspect JKR can’t or won’t write romance—she needs to find a writing partner who can. It sure works well for Cruisie/Mayer!
(spoiler alert)
The book ends on a romantic cliffhanger so now we’ll have to wait a few years for a resolution. Maybe. Or maybe not.
Yes! Lord Julian and Perry need to get married! Still need to work through her fear of pregnancy, but they can use what birth control existed back then
I’m still running a backlog, but I did manage to finish up two long discussions of books that I had read earlier but had only partly written up.
•Harry Turtledove, Ruled Britainnia, 2002. In his afterword, the author says that it would have taken much good luck, both politically and with the weather, for the Spanish Armada to have fetched up intact in England, but Turtledove contends that if the Armada had somehow managed to debark its troops, the seasoned Spanish land forces plausibly could have defeated the English and placed Spain’s candidate, Isabella Clara Eugenia, daughter of Spain’s Philip II, on the English throne. And Turtledove is no stranger to taking an unlikely premise and trying to work out the consequences plausibly.
Here, we open nine years later, in 1597, from the viewpoint of William Shakespeare. In the real world, we know at most the broad outlines of the careers and personalities of Shakespeare and most of his contemporaries, so Turtledove is safe in positing that the playwright is indifferent in religion and much more invested in his career and his art, so that the Bard’s life and works have turned out much as on our timeline (OTL) despite a nominal conversion to Catholicism. One difference is that the Bard has acquired Lieutenant Lope de Vega as both a playwright admirer and as a sort of political minder. On OTL, de Vega (a playwright contemporary with Shakespeare and regarded in the Hispanosphere as comparable in stature) indeed sailed with the Armada in the navy (probably as a marine since he had no known sea training), and was lucky to return alive. After a successful Spanish landing he plausibly could have transferred to the army of occupation as shown in the novel. On OTL, de Vega had made somewhat more progress in his playwright career by 1597 than in the novel, where he is stuck in England far from the theaters of Spain.
The shift in events has preserved the life of Shakespeare’s fellow playwright Christopher Marlowe, on OTL murdered under mysterious circumstances in 1593. Marlowe continues, however, to keep dangerous company. More than a little miffed, he informs Shakespeare, that the Resistance (my word, not the novel’s) has chosen Shakespeare rather than himself to write a play that will inspire, and signal to London, the start of an uprising to throw out the Spaniards. Now that Shakespeare knows about the planned uprising, writing the play is an offer that he can’t refuse; the Resistance has a long reach. In any case, Shakespeare feels at least uncomfortable about the harsh Spanish occupation. The uprising is to start once word reaches England that the slowly dying Philip II has breathed his last. His heir, soon to be Philip III, is known to be much less gifted than his father and he hopefully would not or could not attempt a reconquest. Ironically, the Spanish occupation authorities also commission a play from Shakespeare, one to be performed to Philip II’s English subjects to commemorate his life after his passing. Turtledove includes long excepts from both plays, cobbled together by him mostly by rearranging and adapting lines from genuine works by Shakespeare, Marlowe, and John Fletcher.
I don’t find the plot particularly plausible, even aside from the Spanish takeover. In his afterword, Turtledove does point out that on OTL the Earl of Essex in 1601 paid for a special performance of Richard II just before the Earl attempted something between a coup and a rebellion against Elizabeth I, in order to show that there was precedent for overthrowing an English monarch. But that was an existing play and an uprising confined to London. In the novel, the only point of the Resistance’s commissioning of Shakespeare’s new play is to inspire a few hundred people in the audience to make their way to the Tower and aid in an attempt to free Elizabeth. For this trivial gain (the Resistance plans to raise riots all over London by other means), they bring into the conspiracy not merely Shakespeare but (eventually) the whole theatrical company, with a huge added risk of betrayal. For that matter, what is Elizabeth doing in the Tower of London? Turtledove rationalizes that Philip II spared her life to demonstrate his moral superiority over the regicidal Elizabeth, who had executed Mary Queen of Scots, but if Philip was going to take such a risk, why leave her in London rather than imprisoning her in Spain? I also wonder if Turtledove is not painting the Spanish occupation as harsher than it necessarily would be, given that Spain had an interest in not provoking a rebellion. For example, Turtledove draws a paper distinction between the Spanish Inquisition and the English Inquisition, but the latter operates under the same practices as in Spain. This was not the case on OTL in the Spanish Netherlands. Still, his scenario does not look impossible. Occupations are often harsh, especially in the first decade or so.
Turtledove has done a lot of research and presents a plausible picture of London at the end of the 16th century. I don’t know enough about daily life in OTL to know if the depicted economy has been depressed by the Spanish occupation, but Turtledove may be positing that it has. (Not an inevitable consequence of the conquest. If England were given trade access to the Spanish colonies, its economy might even have been doing better than on OTL.) Whatever the general case, although already a part-owner of an acting company, Shakespeare is living in lodgings, in itself plausible enough considering that his wife and children are back in Stratford, and that we know from a legal deposition that on OTL Shakespeare was still lodging with a family in 1604. What I found rather more surprising was that in the novel Shakespeare is sharing a single room in a sort of rooming house with two other men. Granted, current notions of privacy are recent (in Illinois in the mid-19th century, when riding the legal circuit, Abraham Lincoln was sharing not only hotel rooms but hotel beds with other lawyers). Shakespeare also evidently cannot routinely afford even his own illumination in the evening. Once the long days of summer have passed, he writes either by the candle on the table in the ordinary (a tavern or other establishment offering a set-price meal) where he takes his supper, or by the hearth fire in the rooming house, only burning his own candle when all else fails. Granted, on this timeline as on ours, Shakespeare is sending money to his family in Stratford, but in 1597 on OTL at age 33 he actually bought the second largest house in Stratford, paying probably £120 cash for it (a recorded £60 seems to have been a traditional legal fiction). That was serious money at the time (£10 a year was an above-average income) and I doubt that even in crowded London on OTL someone who could afford such an investment and who was dependent on writing for much of his living would have been putting up with two other sleepers in his room. So we have to imagine that post-Armada the theater business is in serious depression, although the author never hints at this. Turtledove also seems to be flat wrong about pre-Armada Elizabethan divorce law, even for the privileged. On OTL the first private act of Parliament granting a divorce was not until 1667, and annulment (at the time often loosely called divorce) did not serve as an alternative for many beyond Henry VIII, since the legal grounds for it were narrow.
Fortunately, the novel has counterbalancing strengths. Turtledove knows more about Elizabethan English than I ever did, and uses it fairly freely in dialog while keeping the speech comprehensible to moderns. He presents a vivid and plausible picture of life in London at the time and of the conditions under which Shakespeare may have lived and written (at least earlier in his career than the depicted 1597). The altered history gives Shakespeare more years of contact with Marlowe and puts him in close contact with his contemporary great Lope de Vega, who on OTL he may never even have heard of. The characterization is skillful, the action is exciting, and the resolution fairly plausible. Recommended.
(One more coming.)
I’ve never read any Turtledove, but ‘Ruled Britannia’ sounds really interesting!
Turtledove always frustrates me because I don’t know enough historical detail to judge his plausibility, and therefore I don’t read much of him, but Lope de Vega knowing Shakespeare! I must try this one.
There are theories that Shakespeare was secretly Catholic. Many of the authors who write about this are not very credible but there was a solid historical analysis a few years back and I will try to find it.
Jenny, I hope October proves to be a better month for you.
I reread Searching for Always by Jennifer Probst, a 2015 book, and still enjoyed it.
I bought the Let Them Theory by Mel Robbins but haven’t started it yet. It’s nonfiction and I’m hoping maybe it will help me cope with what’s going on in this country.
The new Thursday Murder Club book came out this week so I may pick up that one since I have a gift card from B&N.
Thanks for the heads up on a new Thursday Murder Club book! I’ll be on the lookout for it.
I’m reading the new Thursday Murder Club. It’s quite satisfying after my disappointment with the Netflix version of the first novel. Joyce is the center of most of the humor and her perspective is prominently featured in the 5th book.
Good to hear that I’m not alone in my dislike for the Netflix adaptation, Lisa!
I am halfway through the new TMC and took a break to watch the movie. I liked it, except for the one thing that every reader is mad about.
Karen, I liked it too except for that one thing.
What’s the one thing? I’m most unlikely to watch it.
•S.M. Stirling, To Turn the Tide, Book 1 of Make the Darkness Light, 2024. Despite my typical (but not universal) enjoyment of Stirling’s production, I hesitated before buying this novel, because the setting seemed overused in previous fiction (mostly not by Stirling) and the setup seemed more than a bit contrived. But I ending up on balance liking the book.
As Stirling has done before (the closest parallel is in Conquistador), he starts from a “home” parallel universe that is not quite ours. (In this case, the unnamed U.S. President had served a probably unconstitutional third term starting in 2025, and medical science and some other technology seem more advanced than our timeline plausibly could be by the date of the story opening.) Thus medically advantaged, in 2032, Arthur Vandenberg, a Harvard classics professor who luckily just happens to be former military, plus a few of his graduate students, visit a research institute outside Vienna, Austria, where the physicist inviting them claims to have developed a method for dating Classical archeological relics with unprecedented accuracy.
What exactly the physicist had been planning to do from that point on is not quite clear, since almost as soon as the visitors arrive, a Taiwan crisis boils over and World War III starts. What is clear is that the physicist has actually invented a time machine, and has diverted enough of his research grant to assemble equipment and supplies for an extended expedition or permanent move back in time to the Roman Empire. Possibly he knew or sensed that the war was coming but was slightly off in his timing. The visitors, confused about what is happening, get sent back in time, but the Austrian physicist himself is a fraction of a second too late in joining them and is killed by the transition. By an amazing coincidence, all of this happens just as the blast wave from a nuke hitting Vienna arrives at the institute. (Why a militarily unimportant city in a neutral country should be a first-wave target at all is a question that does eventually get answered, although only in the sequel.) The uptimers arrive in a secluded location in Roman Pannonia Superior (Austria-to-be) in 165 CE/AD. They have been knocked unconscious by the transition and are surrounded by crates of supplies, much of whose value, such as that of the gold, is obvious even to ancient Romans. But by another amazing coincidence, they are found while still senseless by one of the relatively few people of that time and place whose conscience forbids him to simply steal the supplies and slit their throats or sell them into slavery. This is a Jewish merchant who is, however, perfectly ready to cut a mutually profitable deal, and, who, by another amazing coincidence, has the contacts to arrange one. After that much of the setup, the strain on suspension of disbelief eases off considerably.
The uptimers are unsure if they have arrived in a branch timeline or the original one, but, given a massive nuclear exchange that probably killed all their loved ones, they can’t imagine that alterations would make even the original timeline any worse, so they set about propping up and improving Roman civilization and fending off the coming plagues, barbarian invasions, and Dark Ages. (Stirling posits that by 2032 the latter term is coming back into use by scholars, reversing the trend to more optimistically call the period Late Antiquity.) Vandenberg has somehow gotten the idea that if Rome can eventually extend its dominion over the entire world, this will ensure world peace, and that the Empire can be nudged in direction leading ultimately to liberal democracy. This sounds very iffy to me, but for lack of a better idea Vandenberg’s ex-students are willing to help him to give it a try, and in any case the invading barbarians are cruel and ruthless to strangers, even more so than the Romans. In the short term, the current Emperor, Marcus Aurelius, on our timeline was the last of the “Five Good Emperors,” and here he is eventually persuaded not to name his son Commodus as his successor, so possibly more good emperors will follow. The Empire’s two other pressing threats are the succession of barbarian invasions which is just beginning and the Antonine Plague. Innovations in military strategy and technology can hold back the barbarians, especially with simple agricultural improvements to free up manpower for a militia. In the novel, modern historians’ guess that the plague was smallpox fortunately proves correct. This is the one epidemic disease that stood a chance of being handled (by vaccination and quarantine) with uptime knowledge and Roman technology.
Stirling’s heroes are somewhat clearer than the characters in most branching-timeline books are on the difference between technology that can be immediately implemented at the time of arrival, once the downtimers are shown how to make the inovations, and technology that requires first making tools to make the tools. Examples of the first category here include paper, wheelbarrows, and gunpowder for bombs but not guns (all three already in use in China), and also Arabic numerals, horse collars, and improved saddles with stirrups. Guns and steam engines (plus much else), on the other hand, falls into the second category. A big new complication also arrives just at the end of the book as a tantalizer for the sequel. Recommended for readers who like intelligent versions of this sort of thing. (I would caution that the second book also ends with a cliffhanger and the third is not yet out.)
A final note: “Arthur Vandenberg,” none too subtly, means “Arthur from the mountain,” and some legends and composed stories hold that King Arthur sleeps inside some mountain rather than in Avalon as he awaits his return in Britain’s hour of need. I wonder if this will become relevant later in the series.
This sounds interesting. Was there a language problem? Or were the scientists all trained in Latin?
The time travelers are historians rather than scientists. (No details on the dead Austrian physicist.) They speak Latin and some speak Greek, but they have a prolonged period of adjusting to local pronunciation. For instance spelled as ending in -us are pronounced -o as in Italian and Spanish, etc.
That sounds fun. “the strain on suspension of disbelief eases off considerably.” Stirling usually does not permanently injure my suspension of disbelief muscles.
Bob with the ducks is now just about at the opening situation of Donna Andrews’s recent What the Duck?. Unless he’s thirsting for excitement, I hope this doesn’t mean he will soon find a body.
Still not reading at anything like my usual pace. In the early mornings, I work on moving in; then sign on for Day Job and putter as possible between emails; in the evenings, I’ve been watching home-improvement television and then taking a sleep aid because even if I can’t keep my eyes open in the media room, the instant I lie down in bed, my monkey brain starts up full speed. Argh.
1. ‘For the Love of Renovation’ by Barry Bordelon & Jordan Slocum, aka the Brownstone Boys. Thorough & practical, well illustrated, wish the typeface were bigger.
2. ‘Disco Witches of Fire Island’ by Blair Fell. This popped into the ‘also searched for’ line when I was looking at something on AMZ, and was on sale, so I got it. It’s really weird & special. A somewhat fantastical scenario grounded by lived-in struggle. Contains love stories and turns out to be a MM romance, complete with happy-as-can-be ending (set in 1989 and one of the lovers is HIV positive). Full of conflict, but it’s about love & community as bulwarks against despair. Memorable and satisfying, 5 stars.
3. ‘Slow Burn Summer’ by Josie Silver. F/M contemporary set in England, starring an actor (FMC) one year off a bitter divorce and the performers’ agent (MMC) who engages her to act the part of an author. The real author is a bestselling thriller writer who has written a heartrending romance that is too close to home, so he doesn’t want his name on it. Wants to remain completely anonymous, and agrees with his literary agent, MMC’s colleague, to the “ghost author” scheme. Disaster ensues, of course. The book is frequently quite funny but it deals with grief throughout. FMC for her dead marriage, MMC for his dead father (former head of the agency) and for his own bitter divorce / career derailment, the author for his wife. A solid, enjoyable book with real feels. Rounded up to 5 stars.
Oh, and the ebook includes a deleted scene about how the literary agent (partner of MMC’s father) finds out about the author’s book. She is a jagged pill through most of the book but this scene is really gold.
How is the move going ? Are you still at the “most things are in boxes” stage or are you at the “ most things I need every day are out but who knows if they are where I want them and all the decor has yet to be dealt with” stage ?
All of my 42 cartons have been unpacked! My bedroom is habitable! Our DVD player is hooked up (though I don’t yet know which buttons to push to make it go) and my movie hoard is accessible. The cat is fine. I’m doing Day Job fine. The parents are adjusting, and I will soon have my books etc back on shelves.
The husband, meanwhile, is suffering the consequences of having left everything to the last minute and having not thought about how he wants life in retirement to look, but he likes the house and he is getting used to being able to order his own days. His cartons have *not* all been unpacked, but he can exist. 🙂
Wow that’s impressive. Congratulations!
Your energy always astonishes me!
I really liked Slow Burn Summer too. It’s quite a lesson in runaway social media consequences as well as the whole ghost author scheme.
PS – I love Bob.
Hope October will be a good month for you, Jenny.
Read two actual books, turning paper pages, middle of the night with a book light or a small flashlight, which I enjoyed very much.
Two Barbara O’Neal novels When We Believed In Mermaids and The Art Of Inheriting Secrets. The language, the characters and the plot turns and twists in both books were well written. Both rereads. As always. Will be looking for her latest novels.
Got me looking through the TBR pike. Starting Melissa Senate’s The Secret Of Joy. Taking books to Cabo next weeks. A quick trip as the rains have arrived.
Bought two historical books for youngest granddaughter, just turned 12. She will pass on to me when she has read both books.
I’m having a really hard time picking my fave Barbara O’Neals right now. Those two and The Lost Recipe for Happiness are my top 3, I think. Let me know what you think of the new release!
I approve of the ducks. My DIL in Arizona sent me everything she could find on Amazon that had to do with ducks, when I had the stroke. It cheered me up.The bookmark was especially great . “You’re ducking awesome! I may be a tiny duck, but I believe in you! Go do your thing!” I love ducks, and yellow. The poop is very slippery, however. 😂
I finished Rachel Neumeier’s Winter of Ice and Iron before it was due back at the library, and enjoyed it enough to want to read more, but the library has no more, and I didn’t enjoy it enough to spend money on something I’m not likely to want to reread, when I still have a long list of books to buy that I _know_ I want to reread.
I DNFd several books that were not bad, but failed to interest me in their characters. One of those was A Case of Mice and Murder, which several people here liked, but I just could not care. The setting was interesting, and the puzzle seemed likely to lead interesting places, but I quit at about 10% because I just couldn’t be bothered to remember who everybody was, which is not a good sign.
Having finished my reread of Witch King, I am counting down the days until the release of Queen Demon, and not willing to reread anything else Martha Wells at this time.
Jenny, thinking of you and any other Arghers having a difficult time in this most difficult time.
Has anyone here read Ian McEwan’s newest What We Can Know? It’s a Stephen Colbert October Pick and sounds intriguing (scholar in a future world devastated by climate change, “captivated by the freedoms and possibilities of human life at its zenith,” searches for a long-lost brilliant 21st century poem). My library doesn’t carry it yet…
I’ve started listening to An Impossible Fortune, the newest Thursday murder club book. So far I’m enjoying the “pensioners'” shenanigans, the gossipy sounding narrator not so much.
Also read You Are Here by David Nicholls (mentioned in an earlier post), described as a romance about two awkward MCs (M & F, mid/late-30s?) discovering each other through their vulnerabilities on a weeklong walk across the English countryside. I enjoyed its wit and generosity of spirit, but found it emotionally exhausting.
I just started An Impossible Fortune but am reading it so no narrator involved and am enjoying it so far.
Jenny, I hope your October is a vast improvement after your lousy September.
I was away from home for the past couple weeks and didn’t have access to my computer. Didn’t even log in to this chat last Thursday, which would be the first time in years. For reading, I had only my Kindle, and although I have some unread books on it, I wanted to read something soothing. So I re-read Linzi Day’s Midlife in Gretna Green series. I’m on #6 (so far, the last) now, and all of them are as delightful as I remember. Can’t wait for more stories, and the author promises at least a couple more books. Something to look forward to.
Olga – there is a street here named Gretna Green & every time I come across it I laugh about all those historical heroines being kidnapped or willingly going there to elope.
When we were five, four, and four my parents used incubators (dad was a biology prof ) to hatch out a duckling and two chicks for us. The chucks were not exciting but the duckling imprinted on my mom and followed her all around the house and cheeped piteously when she went up or down stairs he couldn’t follow. And took baths in the cake holder.
I want pics of Bob and any ducklings who think he is their dad.
That sounds like so much fun, Debbie!
Off topic, but the income might help after such a stressful month.
I just read Scalzi’s post with a useful link to the searchable database for who is eligible for compensation from Anthropic, and it looks like you could get some compensation.
Have you filed your claim?
https://whatever.scalzi.com/2025/10/02/authors-time-to-get-that-bag/
Jenny, thinking of you and any other Arghers having a difficult time in this most difficult time.
Has anyone here read Ian McEwan’s newest What We Can Know? It’s a Stephen Colbert October Pick and sounds intriguing (scholar in a future world devastated by climate change, “captivated by the freedoms and possibilities of human life at its zenith,” searches for a long-lost brilliant 21st century poem). My library doesn’t carry it yet…
I’ve started listening to An Impossible Fortune, the newest Thursday murder club book. So far I’m enjoying the “pensioners'” shenanigans, the gossipy sounding narrator not so much.
Also read You Are Here by David Nicholls (mentioned in an earlier post), described as a romance about two awkward MCs (M & F, mid/late-30s?) discovering each other through their vulnerabilities on a weeklong walk across the English countryside. I enjoyed its wit and generosity of spirit, but found it emotionally exhausting.
It is October and I feel better if only because there is a pumpkin on my porch. And I am digging out my fun witchy Halloween garb and accessories in an effort to wear them all at least once during the season. I have maybe two pairs of Christmas earrings. I have seemingly unending supply of spooky ones…
And in that spirit I am unabashedly listening to my favorite Spooky rereads. I finished CM Nascosta’s Two for Tea yesterday and have Maybe This Time queued up. Maybe Garden Spells or Sugar Queen next, although the latter feels more like Christmas to me. I also downloaded Mary Oliver reading her poems and an audiobook of Emily Dickinson poems from Hoopla, although I don’t know how much poetry I can listen to in one sitting. And I may look for something by Jane Goodall. I missed the chance to hear her speak once and I regret that now.
I’m going to miss Halloween this year because I’m travelling so I need a book or a novella that I haven’t read…any ideas?
Have you read novels by Anne Bishop? I find myself reading “Written in Red” and the four novels that follow just about every few years. The series makes me happy, which might not be what you wish to read at Halloween…. But for the day after? An excellent choice.
Well Crowbones if I remember correctly is set around their version of Halloween 🙂
I have Written in Red on my wish list so maybe I will try it for the season.
Nicole Kimberling has a lovely funny Halloween themed novella “Black Cat Ink”, third in her Bellingham mysteries. Or the entire Incryptid series by Seanan McGuire seems appropriate for the Halloween season 🙂
I’ve read that, delicious.
If you haven’t read “Hawkes Harbor” by S.E. Hinton (of The Outsiders fame), I found it a fresh take on the vampire scenario. Not a romance. 😉
I tried it and dnf’d it years ago unfortunately.
Has Bob been reading Donna Andrews and deciding the Dad was living the good life and decided to join in the fun.
Catching up, since I’ve been reading but not managing to post here:
I enjoyed The Helios Syndrome by Vivian Shaw (SFF novella about a necromantic consultant who helps solve plane crashes.) Similar in tone to her Greta Helsing books, which I love, but probably not a good choice if you have a strong fear of flying.
Which reminds me—if I never shared it here, I loved Strange New World (latest in the Greta Helsing series) too! Always up for more of Greta and team.
Hemlock & Silver by T. Kingfisher was great, too—dark fairytale vibe, and if you liked the perfumer part of Paladin’s Grace, you might like the search for poison cures part here.
The Blonde Who Came in from the Cold by Ally Carter was a great mix of sheer fun and spy stuff, at least for me. If you didn’t enjoy the Blonde Identity, you probably won’t like this either. But I admire how Carter makes these such fun reads without ignoring the grim underpinnings of spy work. I think that’s such a hard balance.
Highly recommend anything Vivian Shaw!
Almost forgot to include it—I also enjoyed “Data Ghost” by Martha Wells (freely available on the Pseudopod website and podcast.) I don’t know if she intended it to be connected, but it’s a spooky station SF short story that felt like it could have been an early-Corporate Rim incident, or maybe an episode on one of Murderbot’s serials.
(Note: no SecUnits, no direct connection, strictly my own speculation about the setting!)
I am sending good thoughts and extremely gentle hugs. Knitting bones is as important as any other knitting and the only thing you should be cracking are lame jokes.
Meanwhile, the only thing I’ve read is more of the word opera. Book six is up to 115 chapters.
Just finished The Summer War by Naomi Novik. This novella is more along the lines of her fairytale based work, and not the Scholomance novels. But I enjoyed it quite a bit. It was over too soon. I also enjoyed Glorious Rivals, a continuation of the Inheritance Games spinoff series. It’s a YA series in which various people compete in solving games and puzzles with a giant prize on the line. There is a lot of intrigue and a little romance and a serious cliffhanger. Anna Lee Huber’s newest Verity Kent book, A Moment’s Shadow, continues Verity’s sojourn in Ireland during The Troubles. Well researched and written but sad, and also ends on a major cliffhanger. I’ve also been re-reading the Ishmael Jones series by Simon R. Green, which is about an alien disguised as a human who makes a living solving supernatural crimes. So good. Happy reading, all y’all!
I didn’t get around to post last week, so this is what I’ve read lately.
I took Aunt Snack’s advice and changed how I read “Gaslighting” by Deborah Vinall; more as a subject to study and less pressure on mastering the exercises. That definitely helped, so thanks, Aunt Snack! It’s given me a lot of realizations and insights, both about myself and about past and present gaslighters. I still haven’t been able to tell anyone out loud that I’ve been reading it and not much in text either, it still feels very difficult. I think perhaps a part of me is scared that people will tell me I’m nuts, despite this book only having solidified my convictions of ongoing manipulation/gaslighting, and thus throw me back into the circle I’m trying to break out of. But, at least I have finished the book, and it was very very good.
I read “Scepter of memories” by Claribel A. Ortega, 4th in her Witchlings-series. I think it’s been my least favourite so far, although I can’t really put my finger on why. It was still a great read and I will definitely read book 5, whenever it’ll be released, but I felt more of a distance to the characters in this one than in the first 3 books.
I picked up “An Ancient Witch’s Guide to Modern Dating” by Cecilia Edward and DANG are these titles starting to annoy me! Anyway, except for a few spots where details threw me out of the story, it was a nice read. There were a few spots of perspective-change that were a bit weird, and that the ancient witch’s English was so very modern was also… an interesting choice, even when she’d just appeared in the 21st century. That said, the book was less fluffy than I’d expected and had some interesting twists, plus there were a lot of cats. And a cute vet.
Even more witches! I’m really on a witch-binge, it seems. I read “Witch you Would” by Lia Amador and enjoyed it much more than I thought I would. I was not a fan of the female narrator to begin with, but she grew into her role very nicely and ended up suiting her character very well. It’s about this Master Chef-kind of contest, but with spells, and it’s a bit of an enemies to lovers kind of thing, which I normally don’t adore, but it worked. The big misunderstanding one saw from miles away was nicely handled, the MC is very cute, and I think the couple tackled things pretty well all things considered. The FMC has a knack for jumping to conclusions and being nasty, BUT she is very aware of that flaw and communicates. Actually the communicating from both sides is what wins me over, I think. AND a LOT of cat-puns! There was a bit of sex on the page, but it was all right. Recommend.
Would you believe it – I read one more witch-book after that! “Wild is the Witch” by Rachel Griffin was… all right, but I won’t reread it. The FMC is understandably scared and traumatized by a very nasty experience in her past, and her reactions are logical, but that also caused so much problems. She curses her co-worker, whom she thinks is a prick, and he turns out to actually be the gentlest, sweetest boy, so it is again a bit of enemies to lovers and so much misunderstanding and angst that it was kind of painful. He tried to communicate, and she just… did not. Ouch. The colours were a bit too dark for me, at least for right now. But I don’t regret reading it or anything. It also had hope in it, which was good.
I’m currently reading “The Princess Beard” by Kevin Hearne and Delilah S. Dawson, third in their Tales of Pell-series. It’s a lot about identity and what’s masculine and feminine and such, baked into parody of fantasy-tropes and slapstick. I love Kevin Hearne’s Iron Druid-, Seven Kennings- (although I haven’t read the last one yet) and Ink & Sigil-series, but the Tales of Pell… don’t really hit the sweet spot for me. Still, it’s an easy read so I’ll finish it. And I kinda like the tea-magic! I’d love me some of that.
“The Librarians” by Sherry Thomas, a very good book. I was even able to ignore the time skipping of scenes. Excellent characters.
Good to know because I want to read it.
Just so people don’t miss it, it looks like Helen inadvertently posted books under Wednesday, where she discusses:
Light of a Nine Moon, author unspecified, and First Lady by Susan Elizabeth Phillips
Oh, thanks, Patrick! I must have clicked on the wrong Goodreads link to the post.
I remember liking “First Lady” quite a bit, particularly the FMC, and SEP is a bit hit and miss for me. Thanks for reminding me of it.
I finally noticed my typo (autocorrect!). Light of a NILE moon. Author is K. Lyn Smith. Victorian romance in Egypt.
Reading The Incandescent by Emily Tesh. I’m fifteen percent in (reading on my Kindle) and it’s very enjoyable.
It’s awesome!
Sending good vibes for an October that’s much healthier for you than September was.
Thanks for your outstanding Liz Danger series, which I finished a couple weeks ago. I’ve been a reading fan of your work since The Cinderella Deal with Agnes and the Hitman as one of my particular favorites. Okay, enough gushing.
Just read How to Have a Killer Time in D.C. by Sam Lumley, which is a charming murder mystery romp with romantic elements featuring a charming lead character who happens to be autistic and gay in an organic, not in a load-up-the-marginalized-identities way. The author’s familiarity with the D.C.-Maryland region is obvious and adds to the atmospheric narrative that’s engaging with brisk pacing. Lots of intrigue and humor too.
Happy creating!
How to Have a Killer Time in DC looks good, but the Kindle price – at least in the UK – is extortionate! I’ve added it to my wish list in the hope it’ll get more reasonable in time.