Because I haven’t had a new head shot for about fifteen years, maybe twenty, today I dragged Pat Gaffney out to the little fake waterfall beside our favorite grill and said, “Headshots, I need them.” And she was, as always, a peach, and took a million of them.
Among them were a few flukes like this one, which I am going to send to Bob whenever I’m annoyed at him:
And this one, which will always remind me of how much fun I have with Pat:
But now I have narrowed the choices down to six. I think I know which one I like best, but of course Argh must weigh in on it.
I asked Bob which one he liked best and he picked this one:
So not a help. I e-mailed Pat and Mollie and Krissie, too, so now it’s over to you, Argh. Which one of those three headshots scares you the least?
Any of the top six will do, if forced to pick I think I go for the top left.
Moi, I like top left best — or bottom right, which appears to be basically the same photo, just not so closely cropped.
Of course, the scowl is a gem, the embodiment of Aaaaaargh!!!
Bottom middle.
Top left, but they’re all good.
I vote top middle or bottom left.
The fourth and fifth one from the collection of six picks. The pictures have a happy, relaxed vibe.
The three photos where you are smiling and wearing your glasses. I like the glasses. You look amazing.
I could only see three photos at first. Out of the six together. I would go with one, three and six.
Looking at the 6, which are in two rows and 3 columns, my favorites in order are:
Best: row 2 col 2
2nd: row 2 col 1
3rd: row 1 col 1
The scowling one is fun! 😉
Agreed!
Row 2, photo 1 and row 2, photo 2 are the ones I like.
To add to the absence of consensus: From the top left, the first two look over-cropped to me. From the bottom left, the first two show too much of a busy background. Of the rightmost ones, I slightly prefer the bottom one, but the top one is a close second.
Agree with all of these comments and agree with Patrick’s final choices. How’s that for a smattering of consensus?
I vote bottom left!
I like the bottom left, too. Of course I’ll check this again tomorrow and come to a different conclusion.
I’m shocked to find that so many agree with me. My favorite is the bottom left one as well. It looks both friendly and approachable to me.
I agree, bottom left is the most becoming of the good pics. Save the scowl for when Bob deserves it…
Have fun with the rest of your sorting and settling in after your move. Taf
You are limiting yourself. Visit any of several GIF Maker websites and use all six photos rotating at some interval. They all look good to me but keep Annoyed Jenny because reasons (Bob).
No, no, this is for publicity. When people ask for a head shot, they want a small picture that just shows the face. As in, “Look, the author has a face.” Nothing gaudy or moving.
Fine. Bottom Right. But it looks like bottom middle became your Gravitar, and the Gravitar (I think) could be a GIF.
Bottom left and bottom middle. Maybe photoshop away the extra-flyaway hair? A little hair flowing in the breeze is good but you probably don’t want too much.
To left or bottom right
Bottom left
Just to confuse everything, my favorite is middle top or right top.
Upper left or bottom right if it’s really just a headshot you need. Bottom left if you want something less close up. You look most happy and relaxed in those
Bottom left and bottom middle – both eyes visible in glasses frames, great (authentic) smile. Looks like someone who who writes fun, wicked, witty, kind books.
I’d crop a little closer to the face, to minimise busy background and fly away hair.
I realize this isn’t helpful, but I actually like the scowling pic the best . . . if you weren’t scowling. Your glasses are very cool, but they just take up so much space and it’s hard to see the expression in your eyes and those amazing cheekbones. Are there any smiling pics without the glasses that you like?
I’m squinting in all the ones without my glasses.
I actually like the scowling one, it’s the real me, but I don’t want to scare readers.
I love the frames on those glasses, and saving the scowl for when you want that reaction for Bob is a good idea.
When I first used Photoshop after work it caused me to lose track of three hours while I was playing with it. That was decades ago but even early versions of that software had wonderful tools and menu options. Taf
Awww, that’s too bad. Also, you know we don’t scare easily. 🙂
OK, of the six, I like the lower left as just a good fun pic of you.
But for an author headshot, unless you’re planning to go unconventional, I prefer the top center and top right (which I swear are the same pic). I like the more gentle smile for an official pic and I think the head tilt to that side looks better.
They were taken really close together, like seconds apart.
Unless I uploaded the same pic twice. Always a possibility.
Okay cool idea? Photos of both of you scowling at each other
Harder to get since we haven’t seen each other in about fifteen years.
Photoshop to bring you two together? 😀
I like that best too – it embodies a great ‘don’t fluff my duck, sunshine’ intent. That said I think choose the one that you think best reflects you. The all have a great vivacity which is what I get from your strong book characters.
Top left or bottom middle
I prefer the top left one, with the top middle one coming second.
These minimise the distracting background, and your hair looks less wind-tousled. The top right as well as the bottom row make both distracting elements more prominent.
The lower row, with more background showing, would (I think) be less suitable for the sort of small head-shots of authors you see on the dust covers or back covers of books, while the more cropped top row centers you, the author’s portrait, looking as if a reader could have some good fun and laughs with your stories.
Row 2 number 1
First two on the bottom row. And Bob’s favourite of course. Nothing wrong with two pictures of yourself.
If I had to choose, top left and bottom right.
I have had the most horrendous pic taken for my driving licence renewal. I wish I could look half as good as you in those photos.
I vote for bottom right, but cropped slightly less, so there’s just a tiny bit more background. Also, whichever you choose, can you get Photoshop or something to blur the background? That’d solve the distracting background problem and might give you more photo choices.
Top left.
These are so cute! I like the Angry Jenny one a lot, but from the 6 grid, I would use the middle bottom one. To me it seems the most relaxed, and I like that the frames of your glasses are not blocking your eye.
Obviously, the top “Bob” pic is the best! 😀
I like the center bottom of the six -pack. It seems like the best combo of relaxed, profes, interesting, great smile, and lovely.
I like them all, and I can see I’m not alone in that (they’re all getting picked, right?). My favorite is the top left and my second favorite is the bottom right. I think that’s the same shot, just with more background in the bottom right? I like the background–it’s pretty–but I prefer that your face take up more of the shot. I think you look good in all of them (nice job, you and Pat), but I think you look most friendly and approachable in that shot. Even if you don’t feel that approachable, it makes a nice book jacket photo.
They’re all delightful! Bottom left if I had to choose. Looks like it was a fun time, which is the most important thing!
And I put my comment in the wrong spot—hi!
I like the top middle and the bottom left. Even though they’re cute glasses, I wish you had a smiley one of you without them. Great pictures, though!
Bottom left.
The middle one in the bottom row.
I love the two on the left of the bottom row!
Left side, either top left or bottom left. You can see your eyes, and you’re smiling!
Bottom left for me
Top left.
I like the top left. It minimizes the background and it’s my favorite smile. The ones where you’re leaning into the rocks seem to be sending a message, more “I love the rocks” or “I’m heading toward the rocks” than “I’m rocking out.”
I vote for bottom left!
Any of these would be fine, but since you asked #4 AKA bottom left, for no discernible reason
Bottom Left.
I’m also Team Bottom Left. Having met you in person, it seems the most “Jenny” to me of them all.
I have to update my author photo too. It still has dark brown hair and is about 25 lbs ago. Sigh.
In order: (1) Bottom row center (5 out of the 6) and (2) Top row left (1 out of the 6)
Bottom left. I like your flyaway white hair and cool glasses. And smile, of course.
Bottom right❤️
They are all excellent, and I love the glasses and natural hair. I think Bottom Right, though.
Bottom right!
Top row, preferably middle or right.
Problem with bottom center and left is that it looks as if water might drip on you.
I love Bob’s choice but otherwise, bottom left 🙂
Top Left is an excellent head shot for back book flaps and other promotional items. The bottom middle one is also excellent for flyers, events, journalism articles about you. I like these two the best because your eyes are visible through your glasses frames, your face tilt is complimentary, and your smile is genuine – not too wide, not too posed.
For headshot I like row 1 pic 1
Also love both the scowl ans the having fun 1.
Once upon a time I had a pic of you & I together taken at the Loiusville signing for Maybe This Time. I lost it somehow years ago!
My favourite is bottom left .
Bottom left!
I like the ones on the left, both top and bottom row (#1 and #4). You have a great smile! 🙂
Get those rocks outta there! In that case, I’ll take any headshot as long as it is top right.
How elegant you look these days!
Top middle
You know you used a good photographer when people like all of the shots. It is great to have a friend take the photos so you are relaxed and happy during the shoot. Good for you Pat and Jenny! Taf
Top left or bottom left in that order. 😃
For publicity, I would go with bottom left or top left. All six are great but I think that top left in the bottom left shows your great sense of humor and your kindness. And all of those things are true and your fans will love them. Actually, I’m just running into the same problem. I haven’t changed my head shots in six or seven years so now I pulled a few from jury duty which my agents approved.
I gotta tell you I think you look fabulous. Even better than you did. 11 years ago.